Pizza Pot Pies: Easy Italian Recipe

We make pizza pot pies on the nights when we want something good on the table without a long list of steps. This is the kind of cooking we believe in, nothing fussy, just a plate worth sitting down for.

Pizza pot pies are a fun and delicious appetizer or snack that is truly a crowd-pleaser. They are a terrific mash-up of two favorites, pizza and pot pies. This recipe comes together in about 43 minutes from start to finish, which is exactly why it keeps showing up on our table. Below you will find the full ingredient list, the exact method we use, and the small details that make this dish work every single time.

Save

Pizza Pot Pies, freshly made and ready to serve

Why You Will Love Pizza Pot Pies

There are plenty of weeknight dinners out there. Here is why the recipe keeps winning in our kitchen.

• It just works. Great for gatherings and parties.
• It fits a weeknight. Easy to customize with your favorite toppings.
• The whole table eats it. Kid-friendly and fun to eat.
• Dinner in about 43 minutes. Start to plate, including the prep.
• About 24 g of protein per serving. Enough to hold you until morning, not just until nine.

Ingredients You Will Need for Pizza Pot Pies

Everything here is an everyday ingredient. This is the exact list we use for this one, measured the way we actually cook it.

Protein

• 3 oz Turkey Pepperoni chopped

Base

• 1/4 cup Pasta Sauce or Pizza Sauce use a meatless variety

Dairy

• 1 tbsp Butter softened

Seasoning

• 1/4 tsp Salt
• 1/4 tsp Garlic Powder
• 1/4 tsp Italian Seasoning plus extra as topping if desired
• Pinch of Black Pepper

Pantry

• 1/2 tbsp Olive Oil
• Cooking Spray or oil to grease the tins
• 8 Refrigerated Biscuits 16 ounce package
• 7 to 8 ounces Shredded Mozzarella

A quick word on the parts that matter most in it:

• Italian Seasoning plus extra as topping if desired. It does the seasoning work of six separate jars, which is exactly why it belongs here.
• Refrigerated Biscuits 16 ounce package. It is an everyday ingredient doing quiet, useful work here.
• Pasta Sauce or Pizza Sauce use a meatless variety. Cook it a minute short of the package time, since it keeps cooking once it hits the hot sauce.

Prefer metric? The recipe card below switches every amount over for you.

Save

Pizza Pot Pies, freshly made and ready to serve

How to Make Pizza Pot Pies

Here is exactly how we make the dish: about 20 minutes of prep and roughly 23 minutes of cooking.

What you need: Large Skillet, Large Pot, Oven, Baking Dish.

1. Combine the softened butter, olive oil, salt, garlic powder, Italian seasoning, and black pepper in a small bowl. Stir well to combine.
2. Preheat the oven to 350 F and prepare the muffin tins.
3. Spray or oil the muffin pan lightly with the cooking spray. Use a paper towel to dab away excess oil so that it is not pooling at the bottom of the tins.
4. Open the biscuit package and separate them. Place a biscuit in the muffin tin and press gently to mold on the bottom and on the sides. Continue molding and pressing as it bounces back until it is securely in the pan. Repeat with the rest of the biscuits.
5. Use a fork to prick the biscuits a few times on the bottoms and sides.
6. Brush the inside of the biscuits with the prepared butter mixture.
7. Then brush the inside lightly with the pasta sauce about 1/2 heaping teaspoon.
8. Fill with 1 heaping tablespoon of mozzarella cheese. Then with 1/2 heaping tablespoon turkey pepperoni.
9. Repeat with 1 tablespoon mozzarella and 1/2 tablespoon turkey pepperoni. Finally, sprinkle the top with a pinch of Italian seasoning if desired.
10. Repeat with the rest of the biscuit cups. If you are using individual foil cups, place them on a sheet pan before baking.
11. Bake 20 to 23 minutes or until the edges of the biscuit crust are golden brown and the cheese is melted.
12. Gently lift them out of the muffin pan, arrange them on a plate or platter and serve. Or you can put them out in the individual tins if desired.

That is the whole method. Nothing here needs special technique, just a little attention at the right moments.

Tips for the Best Pizza Pot Pies

None of this is complicated, but these are the small habits that separate a good plate of this recipe from a great one.

• Give everything room on the pan. Crowded vegetables steam instead of roasting.
• Cut everything to a similar size so it all finishes at the same time. Cut everything to a similar size so it all finishes at the same time.
• Line the pan with parchment for easy cleanup and better release. Line the pan with parchment for easy cleanup and better release.
• Read the steps once before you start. Knowing what is coming makes the whole thing calmer.
• Have everything measured and within reach before the heat goes on. Have everything measured and within reach before the heat goes on.

Taste as you go and adjust the seasoning at the end rather than the beginning. This dish rewards a little attention right at the finish.

Save

Pizza Pot Pies, freshly made and ready to serve

Variations and Add Ins

Pizza pot pies takes changes well, so treat the recipe above as a starting point rather than a set of rules. These are the swaps we come back to most often.

• Change the shape. Anything with ridges or curves holds this sauce well.
• Add protein. Chicken, beef or shrimp turn it into a full dinner.
• Sneak in vegetables. Spinach, peas or broccoli stir in at the end with no fuss.
• Make it lighter. Half and half in place of cream keeps it silky with less richness.
• Change the herbs. Fresh parsley, basil or dill at the end each send it somewhere slightly different for no extra effort.
• Make it a bigger meal. Serve it over rice or with warm bread and it stretches to feed another person or two.

Change one thing at a time rather than three. That way you find out what you actually like in the recipe instead of guessing at the end.

How to Store and Reheat Pizza Pot Pies

Leftovers keep in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to three days. Pasta drinks up sauce as it sits, so add a splash of broth or cream when you reheat it and stir until it loosens up again.

If you are cooking ahead on purpose, prep the components and keep them separate until you are ready. It takes a few minutes off a busy evening and this one holds its texture far better that way.

Save

Pizza Pot Pies, freshly made and ready to serve

What to Serve With Pizza Pot Pies

It carries a plate on its own, but a few simple things turn it into a proper dinner.

• A green salad with a sharp dressing. Simple, and it soaks up everything on the plate.
• Garlic bread. A little contrast keeps the whole plate from feeling heavy.
• Roasted broccoli. Easy to put together while the main event finishes.
• A glass of sparkling water with lemon. The kind of small addition that makes dinner feel finished.

Pizza Pot Pies FAQ

Can I make Pizza Pot Pies ahead of time?

Yes. You can prep the components a day ahead and keep them covered in the refrigerator, then finish the dish when you are ready to eat. It saves real time on a busy evening.

Can I use something other than Italian Seasoning plus extra as topping if desired?

You can. Use what you have and keep the quantity about the same. The cooking time may shift slightly, so go by how this recipe looks rather than the clock.

How long does Pizza Pot Pies take?

About 43 minutes from start to finish, including roughly 20 minutes of hands on prep. The first time through may run a little longer.

Can I double the recipe?

Yes. Doubling works well here. Use a larger pan so nothing crowds, and expect this dish to need a little more time in the heat.

How do I store leftovers?

Leftovers keep in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to three days.

Can I freeze Pizza Pot Pies?

Yes, in an airtight container for up to three months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator and reheat gently so the texture holds.

Simple Food That Earns Its Place

If you make pizza pot pies, we hope it turns into one of those recipes you stop measuring after a while, the one you can put together on a Tuesday without thinking too hard about it. That is the best thing a recipe can become, not a special occasion dish but a reliable one.

If something worked especially well for you, or you found a swap worth passing on, we would genuinely like to hear about it. Most of the small improvements in our recipes started as somebody else’s idea.

Simple ingredients, an honest method, and a plate worth sitting down for. That is all we are ever after.