Creamy Potato Salad with Turkey Bacon and Cheddar

We make this creamy potato salad whenever we want a loaded, crowd-pleasing side that feels a little extra special. Tender red potatoes are tossed in a tangy mayo and sour cream dressing with crispy turkey bacon, sharp cheddar, red onion, and dill pickles for a rich, savory salad with a smoky, cheesy twist. That is real food for real life, creamy, hearty, and full of flavor, the kind of creamy potato salad that loads up a classic with all the best steakhouse-style toppings, perfect for a summer barbecue or potluck, and even better the next day once the flavors have had time to meld.

What makes this creamy potato salad so good is the balance of creamy, tangy, and savory in every bite. Soft potatoes soak up a rich, tangy dressing, while turkey bacon, cheddar, and dill pickles add smoky, cheesy, and briny notes. It is the kind of indulgent, crowd-pleasing creamy potato salad that proves a few loaded toppings can turn a simple side into the star of the table.

Save

Tender potatoes in a tangy creamy dressing loaded with turkey bacon and sharp cheddar, this creamy potato salad is a loaded crowd-pleaser.

Why You Will Love This Creamy Potato Salad

• It is creamy. This creamy potato salad has a rich, tangy dressing.
• It is loaded. Turkey bacon and cheddar make it extra special.
• It is savory. Smoky, cheesy, and briny notes in every bite.
• It is a crowd-pleaser. A guaranteed hit at any cookout.
• It is make-ahead friendly. Even better after chilling.
• It is hearty. Substantial enough to be a favorite side.

What Makes This Creamy Potato Salad So Good

It starts with the potatoes. Tender red potatoes form the creamy, satisfying base of this creamy potato salad, holding their shape beautifully while soaking up the tangy dressing.

Then comes the creamy dressing. A tangy blend of mayonnaise, sour cream, Dijon mustard, and apple cider vinegar coats everything in a rich, smooth dressing that gives this creamy potato salad its signature flavor.

Next are the loaded toppings. Crispy turkey bacon, sharp cheddar cheese, and tangy dill pickles add smoky, cheesy, and briny notes that make this creamy potato salad feel rich and indulgent.

Finally, the red onion and herbs tie it all together. Sharp red onion adds a zesty crunch while fresh parsley and a scatter of chives bring a bright, fresh lift that balances the rich, creamy dressing.

Optional Pro Tip: Do Not Overcook the Potatoes and Chill Before Serving

The secret to a great creamy potato salad starts with perfectly cooked potatoes. Boil them just until fork tender, soft enough to pierce easily but still holding their shape. Overcooked potatoes turn mushy and fall apart when stirred, while properly cooked ones keep a pleasant, creamy bite. It also helps to let the potatoes cool to room temperature before mixing, since adding the dressing to hot potatoes can cause it to separate and become runny.

The other key is to chill the salad before serving. Refrigerating it for at least an hour lets the flavors meld and the dressing thicken, so every bite is creamy and well seasoned. In fact, this creamy potato salad often tastes even better the next day. When stirring everything together, be gentle so the potatoes keep their shape, and remember that the turkey bacon, cheddar, and pickles all add salt, so taste before adding any extra.

Tips for the Best Creamy Potato Salad

• Use red potatoes. They hold their shape and need no peeling.
• Do not overcook. Cook just until fork tender so they stay firm.
• Cool before mixing. Hot potatoes can make the dressing runny.
• Stir gently. Keep the potatoes from mashing as you mix.
• Go easy on salt. The turkey bacon, cheese, and pickles add plenty.
• Chill it. At least an hour for the flavors to meld.
• Add toppings fresh. Reserve some turkey bacon for the top.
• Cut evenly. Uniform potato pieces make every bite balanced.
• Taste and adjust. Season to your preference before serving.

Variations and Add Ins

This salad is wonderfully easy to adapt. Here are a few simple ways to make this creamy potato salad your own.

• Add eggs. Chopped hard-boiled eggs make it deli-style.
• Add celery. Diced celery brings extra fresh crunch.
• Switch the cheese. Try pepper jack or crumbled feta.
• Lighten it up. Use Greek yogurt for part of the mayo.
• Add a splash. A little pickle juice deepens the tang.
• Add heat. Diced jalapeno or a pinch of cayenne.
• Add smoky color. A sprinkle of smoked paprika on top.
• Switch the onion. Use green onions in place of red onion.
• Add more herbs. Fresh dill is wonderful here too.

How to Store and Make Ahead

This creamy potato salad is wonderful for making ahead, which makes it a reliable choice for gatherings. In fact, it often tastes even better after resting, since the flavors have more time to meld and the dressing thickens. Making it a few hours or even the night before means it is ready to go when you are.

If you are making it well ahead, you can prepare everything and stir it together, then reserve a little turkey bacon and cheddar to scatter over the top closer to serving. This keeps those loaded toppings looking and tasting their freshest while still letting the potatoes soak up all that creamy flavor.

Store this creamy potato salad in an airtight container in the refrigerator, where it keeps well for several days. Because it is dressed with mayonnaise and sour cream, keep it chilled and avoid leaving it out too long, especially in warm weather. Give it a gentle stir before serving, as the dressing may settle as it sits.

Serving Suggestions for Creamy Potato Salad

This creamy potato salad is a cookout favorite, which makes it a natural partner for anything off the grill. Its rich, creamy texture is a satisfying match for smoky, savory mains, sitting happily alongside grilled chicken, burgers, steak, and barbecue at any summer gathering.

It is just as at home on a picnic table or a potluck spread. Bring it to a backyard barbecue where its loaded toppings always get noticed, serve it as a hearty side at a family dinner, or set it out alongside other cookout classics for a spread everyone will love.

• With grilled steak. A rich, creamy side for the main.
• With burgers. A loaded, hearty cookout favorite.
• With barbecue. The creamy texture balances smoky flavors.
• At a potluck. Those loaded toppings always get noticed.
• With grilled chicken. A satisfying, savory pairing.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this creamy potato salad?

It is a loaded, steakhouse-style potato salad made with tender red potatoes in a tangy mayo and sour cream dressing with crispy turkey bacon, sharp cheddar, red onion, and dill pickles.

What potatoes work best?

Red potatoes are ideal because they hold their shape well and have a creamy texture. Their thin skins need no peeling. Yukon Gold potatoes also work nicely.

Why cool the potatoes before mixing?

Adding the creamy dressing to hot potatoes can cause it to separate and turn runny. Letting them cool first keeps the dressing thick, creamy, and clinging to every piece.

Can I make it ahead?

Absolutely. It often tastes even better made ahead as the flavors meld and the dressing thickens. Reserve some turkey bacon and cheddar to add fresh before serving.

How do I keep the potatoes from getting mushy?

Cook them just until fork tender and no longer, then stir gently when combining. Overcooking or rough stirring is what causes potatoes to break down and turn mushy.

Can I lighten it up?

Yes. Swap part of the mayonnaise for plain Greek yogurt for a lighter dressing that is still creamy and tangy. It is an easy way to cut some of the richness.

How much salt should I add?

Add salt sparingly and taste as you go. The turkey bacon, cheddar, and dill pickles all bring saltiness, so it is best to season at the end once everything is combined.

What can I add to it?

Chopped hard-boiled eggs make it deli-style, while celery adds crunch. A splash of pickle juice, a little jalapeno, or fresh dill are all great ways to add flavor.

How long does it keep?

It keeps well in an airtight container in the refrigerator for several days. Keep it chilled since it contains mayonnaise and sour cream, and stir gently before serving.

What should I serve with it?

It pairs beautifully with grilled steak, burgers, chicken, and barbecue, and works as a hearty, loaded side at any cookout, potluck, or everyday meal.

A Loaded Cookout Favorite

Creamy, hearty, and loaded with all the best toppings, this creamy potato salad is the kind of side that steals the show at any cookout. It is easy to make, endlessly adaptable, and only gets better as it sits, making it a perfect choice for barbecues, potlucks, and family dinners alike.

If you love a great potato salad, try another favorite like our Mediterranean potato salad next. However you make it, we hope this creamy potato salad brings a little loaded, creamy goodness to your table.